APRS Resources

Letter to Cabinet Secretary on Galloway National Park

Following the decision not to designate Galloway as Scotland’s next National Park we have written to Mairi Gougeon, the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs, Land Reform and Islands about the failure in the process of the designation, and the changes that could be made in the Natural Environment Bill to clarify the process of designating a National Park. Written 25 June 2025

Dear Ms Gougeon

Re: Galloway and Ayrshire National Park

We are obviously extremely disappointed, along with many others, with the decision not to designate Scotland’s next National Park in Galloway and Ayrshire. We believe that a very strong case had been made that a National Park would be highly beneficial to the economic outlook, natural and cultural heritage, and landscapes of the area. We also believe that the consultation report demonstrated that there is a need for a body capable of co-ordinating action to address the specific needs of the area.

In the statement on the decision on the Galloway proposal, you indicated that the Scottish Government was very supportive of Scotland’s existing National Parks and would consider proposals for new National Parks when they came forward.

Whilst this is welcomed, we would like to see the Government review the process of designation and look at changes that could be made in laying out a clear process by additional amendments to the National Parks Act to be made through the Natural Environment Bill. 

Our own observations of some of the issues we saw with the process of the designation for the National park include:  

  • An over-reliance on volunteers, even after the decision was taken that Galloway would be the location for the proposed new National Park, which placed an unsustainable burden on local communities. The process of designating a National Park, once the area has been decided on, should be Government-led, reflecting that a National Park is a national designation.
  • A lack of timely, clear information from the government, leading to confusion and the spread of misinformation.  The gap between the announcement and when information about the proposed National Park was published, allowed uncertainty and misinformation to grow which went mostly unchallenged by the Government. Even when the consultation was published there was a lack of clarity over aspects of what was being proposed, and there was still a heavy reliance on the nomination information put together by the volunteers rather than a definite proposal by the Government for the benefit of Scotland.
  • A consultation process that was not designed as a poll, yet appeared to be treated as one in its interpretation of support, with no weighting given for whether arguments for or against the National Park had any basis in evidence.
  • Concerns over the role and perceived impartiality of NatureScot, which appeared constrained in advocating for the benefits of National Parks. NatureScot’s professional advice relating to biodiversity, delivered in a separate Report to Ministers at the same time as the main Reporter recommendations seems to have been set aside and ignored, and not mentioned in your announcement.

We believe these issues point to the need for a stronger, more transparent and better-resourced statutory process. The upcoming Natural Environment Bill offers a timely opportunity to address these concerns. We have some outline proposals to improve the process for proposing and designating a new National Park. In summary our proposals are:

  • That the Scottish Government should produce guidance on how a suggested area has to meet the criteria in the 2000 Act.
  • That, at the point that Scottish Ministers formally propose a new National Park, and set the Reporting process underway, a much firmer vision of the National Park they are proposing should be published.
  • Consideration of who takes on the role of the reporter: the Reporter should be required to produce its recommendations independently, and their recommendations should be evidence based and for the benefit of the people of Scotland (both current and future generations).

We would welcome the chance to engage further on how the Natural Environment Bill could support improvements to the designation process and to meet with you to discuss.

Yours sincerely,

 Kat Jones, Director APRS

Back
to top