If you are concerned about the proposed 1GW data centre at Chapelcross, you can make your views known by submitting a formal objection to Dumfries and Galloway Council. You do not need to be a planning expert, and you do not need to write a long or technical response.
The deadline is 19 November (extended from 29 October)
What is the application?
The application is for Planning in Principle for a 1000MW capacity hyperscale data centre on fields north of the decommissioned nuclear power station at Chapelcross, Dumfries and Galloway. The documents are available on the Dumfries and Galloway Planning Portal 26/1649/PIP
The headline figures, all taken from the applicant’s own documents:
- Eight data centre buildings up to 40 metres tall, roughly the height of a 13 storey block, with a substation up to 15 metres and a training centre and industrial units up to 9 metres.
- Each data centre building would have up to 42 standby generators, air-cooled chillers, fuel tanks, transformers and batteries.
- Construction would run for about 8 years, from 2027 to 2035.
- The main application document does not give the IT capacity of the data centre. Press reports describe it as 1 Gigawatt (1,000 MW). And other documents in the application say there will be eight buildings each “assumed to be 120 MW” (Sustainability Statement). The EIA Report Appendix 15-2 gives it as “640 MW IT load” ; and up to 336 generators of 3,200 kW each which is about 1,075 megawatts of standby generation
No operator or end user is named. The application is for permission in principle (PPP). Approval of the PPP would establish the principle of a data centre on this site, with much of the detailed design dealt with later. We do not believe that a Planning in Principle application is sufficient to understand what is actually being proposed, and the impacts, in such a huge and environmentally damaging development such as a hyperscale data centre.
Interactive Map of the site and nearby features
We are excited to use this new way of helping communities find out information about the places that hyperscale data centres are proposed. New layers will follow as the tool develops. Thank you to Andrew Hall of Turbine Education for his inspiration and work to create this!
Click the picture to visit the map.

Tips for Writing an Effective Planning Objection.
The key to writing an effective planning objection is to refer to ‘material planning considerations’. These are matters that the planning authority can take into account when deciding whether the development is acceptable which includes elements of National Planning Framework 4 and the Local Development Plan. We lay out a few points to use below.
A short objection making two or three well-supported points is likely to be more useful than a long letter simply expressing general opposition.
Pick the points that matter to you and put them in your own words; personal letters carry more weight than copied text.
Reasons to Object to this planning application
This application cannot be considered until the Scottish Government produces its guidance
On 16 September 2026, the Scottish Parliament agreed that no decisions on hyperscale data centres should be made before new national planning guidance is produced covering environmental, spatial, energy and community impacts. If decisions cannot be made without the guidance, then how can a consultation, and the decision-making processes, take place without this guidance, which will form a very important material consideration. The Scottish Government voted for this pause too and they should make their position clear by maintaining a ‘no support’ policy until the guidance is in place, and by calling in this application.
Size and Energy Use
This data centre, at 1000MW/ 960MW, would be bigger than any data centre currently operating in the world according to EpochAI which records the biggest data centres in the world at all stages of construction. Elon Musk’s Colossus II in Memphis is the biggest data centre currently in operation with with 946MW of IT capacity.
The Chapelcross data centre would use 7 million MWh of electricity a year, if operating at the estimated 80% capacity of AI data centres, which is equivalent to almost a third (31%) of all the electricity used in Scotland in 2024 and the equivalent of 2.2 million households. [1]
Most data centres in Scotland are between 1-5MW and the average data centre in Europe in 2025 was 5MW according to the European Union. Only 1% of data centres in Europe, according to the European Data Centre Association, were bigger than 20MW. The Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology (POST) reported that, in 2024, there was an estimated 30MW of data centre capacity in Scotland, and 1048MW across the whole London area, the largest data centre market in Europe and the second largest in the world after North Virginia USA.
Given the huge construction, permitting and power-sourcing difficulties Colossus II has had in Memphis, and that it has resorted to hugely damaging gas turbine generators to run, it seems that a project as huge as this, many hundreds of times bigger than Scotland’s existing data centres, is unlikely to be able to be delivered.
Huge amounts of Air Pollution related to Diesel Generators:
It is pretty mind blowing that a facility that would use as much energy as nearly a third of the Scottish Economy, would be seeking to have diesel backup generators. But it seems that it is, so here is our analysis.
- The application states that there will be 312 or 336 back-up generators of 3.2MW (depending which document you look at). In order to keep them in working order, all generators need to be tested regularly. A study on the Larbert data centre, which proposed 200 generators of the same 3.2MW size, showed that at least three generators would need to run every working day of the year to get through the testing regime and it would make the site one of Scotland’s top 10 polluters of Nitrous Oxides. There are more than 50% more generators proposed in this case.
- The testing regime of the generators at Chapelcross, when compared to that from the EIA at Larbert, which is far more detailed, seems insufficient. We do not believe that the Chapelcross EIA has sufficiently modelled either emissions impacts or noise, both of which we believe will be far higher than noted.
- The proposal says that it will be using HVO (biodiesel) but this still gives rise to NOx emissions. The vast quantities of fuel required for this huge data centre, plus the additional price of HVO compared to diesel make it unlikely that this will be able to be used operationally.
- The chimneys for the diesel generators are more or less the same height as the building, and SCR systems are not mentioned (these are the scrubbers that significantly reduce NOx emissions) so we believe that the emissions will be unmitigated.
Climate Impacts
The developer themselves has judged that the site will have whole-life emissions of 23.2 million tonnes CO₂e,which is “moderate adverse and Significant” and estimate this would take up 8.12% of Scotland’s carbon budget and 76.98% of Dumfries and Galloway’s carbon budget.
The application suggests the development will have an energy demand of 960MW and run 24/7 using a connection or connections to the electricity grid. Data centres can’t usually dial usage up and down so they use energy even when the wind is not blowing and the carbon intensity of the grid is high, which means it is appropriate to use the average for grid carbon intensity in calculating emissions for them.
By our calculations taking an average load factor of 80% the development will use:
960 x 0.80 x 24 x 365 = 6,728,000 MWh (6.7 TWh) of energy a year. For illustration of the scale of use, the total energy consumption of Scotland in 2024 was 21.7 TWh so the proposal’s predicted usage is comparable to 31% of the whole of Scotland’s energy use in 2024. Using the UK Government’s figure for carbon intensity of electricity from the UK grid:- 0.177 kgCO₂e/kWh for 2025) results in projected greenhouse gas emissions for the development of around 1.2 million tonnes CO₂e per year (based on 2025 figures).
This is the figure from the electricity alone and does not include the impacts of testing the diesel generators and any emergency use of the generators.
The developer makes the case that they will use renewables from the surrounding area, however renewables could only provide a very small proportion of the energy required for a 1000 MW data centre. Onshore wind has a 0.26 load factor meaning that Whitelee windfarms (Scotland’s largest onshore windfarm, just south of Glasgow) would have to run for eight years to provide the energy this data centre would need in a year. Since data centres run on a 24/7 profile, they would draw a huge amount of energy from the grid whether or not the wind is blowing. This would mean that it would increase the demand for gas and/or nuclear energy when wind cannot provide the energy, potentially (since this is such a big energy demand) increasing the carbon intensity of the grid.
Renewable energy installations locally have been consented on the basis that they would connect to the grid, which would contribute to decarbonisation of the UK, rather than as a private wire to a data centre. Emissions from data centres have not been accounted for within Scotland’s climate change plan and so diverting renewable energy to a data centre rather than using to power the grid would further impact our climate targets
Major Accidents and hazardous substances have not been sufficiently examined in the EIA
The Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is insufficient for the application that has been presented, since the scoping report did not mention the generators and battery storage (BESS) so the application cannot be considered on the basis of this EIA.
- The Scoping Report (which lays out what the EIA should contain) said “diesel generators will not be installed”, there would be “no battery storage” and “no combustion sources on-site”. Refrigerant is not mentioned anywhere in the Scoping Report.
- However, the Planning Permission in Principle application includes up to 42 generators per building, fuel tanks and batteries and about 241 tonnes of the refrigerant R32, an extremely flammable gas. Major accident and hazardous substances controls for such gases begin at 10 tonnes.
- The Health and Safety Executive’s scoping advice was given on the scheme with no generators (response of 1st April 2026).
- The quantity of fuel that would be stored is not given, but a calculation made of running the generators for a 12 hour emergency generation would exceed the 2,500 tonne diesel threshold for major accident controls. The Uptime Institutes standards have a minimum fuel storage requirement of 12 hours of operation.
The power supply is left out, and the grid connection is not shown, cumulative impact has not been sufficiently assessed.
- The private wires and connection to the grid are not shown as part of the application, even though the ‘Raeshaw farms’ ruling makes it clear that applications that rely on grid connections for their operation must include the grid connections as part of the assessment of the impacts.
- The cumulative impact of the proposal with the planned hydrogen plant, or the proposed private wire renewables and associated grid infrastructure that would be required, have not been assessed
The site is not brownfield it is on agricultural land and land that is a prime example of unimproved ancient grassland with rare plants and butterflies.
The developer refers to the site as ‘predominantly brownfield’ in their Planning Statement and speaks of “repurposing of the former Chapelcross Nuclear Power Station site”. But the site lies north of the power station and outside its Nuclear Licensed Area
The 2024 prospectus for development at the site notes that the area which is now being proposed for the data centre as being outside the nuclear licenced site. The prospectus says ‘ this land is owned by NDA but is outside of Nuclear Licensed area and therefore potentially available for development in the short-medium term. It comprises a mix of brownfield land (former airfield) and greenfield land to the north, south and east of the former Power Station which is currently in low intensity agricultural use (grazing).”
The applicant’s own habitat survey records 0.04 hectares of building and 3.04 hectares of hardstanding, against 43.8 hectares of grassland when combining with the information from Table 9-5. Its Scoping Report records about 17 hectares of Class 4.1 and 16 hectares of Class 3.2 agricultural land.
Some of the region’s best species-rich grassland would be lost
NatureScot told the Council at scoping stage that the uncultivated areas (which are on the old airfield) at Chapelcross “now support some of the best examples of species rich grassland in the region, supporting rarities such as butterfly orchid and dingy skipper butterfly”, and that “thorough survey and assessment will be required to determine if these areas are suitable for development”.
NatureScot recommended avoidance rather than mitigation or compensation. The applicant has reported in Chapter 9 of the EIA that “permanent loss of approximately 8ha of semi-improved neutral grassland, representing approximately 90% of this habitat type within the Site”.
Noise Pollution
The chillers, air handling plant and substation would run around the clock. We believe that the noise impact, especially from testing the diesel generators, and when they would be working in the case of a power cut, will take the noise well over thresholds.
There is no plan for waste heat
The amount of the energy this proposal would use (nearly a third of the electricity used in the whole Scottish economy) makes the use of waste heat only a token gesture even if there was a plan for using it. The applicant has not offered a plan for how any waste heat could be reused. In order for waste heat to be reused there needs to be a heat network to connect to, or one needs to be planned for new homes. In order for this to happen, data centres of an appropriate size should be built in places where a heat network is planned.
Economic benefits inflated
Data centres are highly automated. This application claims it would “support approximately 432 on-site Full-Time Equivalents” once operating but doesn’t explain how this figure is achieved, particularly as we do not know who the operator will be and what their plans for operating the site will be. Our research on data centre jobs surveying the best available data from all over the world suggests that a typical data centre employs 20-50 people and the very largest around 100.
More information on this can be found in our report https://aprs.scot/resources/employment-and-data-centres-aprs-report/
Notes
[1] Average Load factor of a data centre 80% (NESO states that the ‘fleet wide average load factor is 70%, yet this has been judged to increase to 80-85% for hyperscale facilities and data centres dealing predominately with AI.)
So this is 1000 x 0.8 x 24 x 365 = 7 million MWh
Total Energy consumption in 2024 in Scotland 21.7 TWh
electricity usage of average Scottish home in a year 3140KWh
Number of households in Scotland in 2024 2,550,000
Keep up to date with APRS
We send out an email update, usually about 6 times a year (but with a very busy campaign at the moment it is a bit more often).
Donate
Every donation is greatly appreciated by APRS, so thank you for choosing our charity and helping us to continue our work.