APRS News

Questions in the Parliament on Data Centres

We were in touch with Ariane Burgess, MSP and Convener of the Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee of the Scottish Parliament, about our concerns over Data Centres. She put some questions to the Minister responsible for planning which have just been published.

We wanted to know whether all data centres are being supported as National Developments in NPF4, or just those supporting National development 12: the Digital Network. Also what the definition of a Green data centre is, as it is it unclear the standards that are being required to qualify as a green data centre and what strategic planning is being done regarding energy intensive infrastructure like data centres.

You can see the answers below.

Question S6W-41362

  • Asked by: Ariane Burgess, MSP for Highlands and Islands, Scottish Green Party
  • Date lodged: 15 October 2025
  • Current status: Answered by Ivan McKee on 28 October 2025

To ask the Scottish Government what criteria are used to determine whether a data centre qualifies as a “green data centre” under the fourth National Planning Framework (NPF4), and whether AI-focused data centres are included in the scope of national developments under NPF4


Answer

National Planning Framework 4 (NPF4) designates all green data centres of a major scale as part of National Development 12: Digital Fibre Network. This includes AI-focused green data centres meeting the major development criteria.

It will be for the planning authority to interpret and apply NPF4 according to the circumstances of each individual case. To be considered a green data centre, planning authorities may wish to consider criteria such as the extent to which the data centre is powered from renewable energy sources; makes use of energy efficient technologies; seeks to minimise water consumption; and supports the re-use of excess heat.

Question S6W-41364

  • Asked by: Ariane Burgess, MSP for Highlands and Islands, Scottish Green Party
  • Date lodged: 15 October 2025
  • Current status: Answered by Ivan McKee on 28 October 2025

To ask the Scottish Government, regarding any implications for its energy strategy, what impact it anticipates that the growth of AI and data centres will have on the (a) energy grid and (b) electricity demand in Scotland; whether it plans to introduce specific planning guidance for energy-intensive developments, such as AI data centres, and what strategic planning is being undertaken to accommodate any infrastructure demands of AI technologies, including data centres and high-performance computing.


Answer

There is an opportunity for Scotland to become a leader in green data centres given our capacity to generate energy from renewable sources.

In 2023, 70% of electricity generated in Scotland was from renewable sources – a marked increase compared to less than one-third (32%) a decade previously. As of June 2025, there is an estimated capacity of 76.5 GW of renewable energy projects, including storage, in the planning pipeline in Scotland. This means there is ample opportunity to use excess renewable generation for data centres, helping to reduce the impact and taxpayer costs of network constraints, with £390 million paid to Scottish wind farm operators in 2024 alone. As the National Energy System Operator (NESO) recognised in its 2025 Future Energy Scenarios, up to a fifth of Great Britain’s future data centre demand could be based in Scotland.

While we have no immediate plans to introduce planning guidance for energy-intensive developments, strategic planning is being undertaken by the Scottish Government to accommodate any infrastructure demands of AI technologies, such as AI data centres. Together with the UK and Welsh Governments, we have jointly commissioned NESO to produce a Strategic Spatial Energy Plan (SSEP) for Great Britain. The SSEP will spatially optimise a specified volume of flexible data centre demand (1-2GW). This will indicate where opportunities for energy system benefits exist, such as co-location of renewables and data centres, supporting the development of government policy on the spatial location of data centre demand. The Regional Energy Strategic Plan for Scotland will further enable the coordinated development of the energy system across multiple vectors.

Question S6W-41361

  • Asked by: Ariane Burgess, MSP for Highlands and Islands, Scottish Green Party
  • Date lodged: 15 October 2025
  • Current status: Answered by Ivan McKee on 28 October 2025

To ask the Scottish Government whether all data centres are considered national developments under the fourth National Planning Framework, or only those that support the Digital Fibre Network ambition.


Answer

National Planning Framework 4 (NPF4) designates all green data centres of a major scale as part of National Development 12: Digital Fibre Network. What constitutes a major development is defined within the The Town and Country Planning (Hierarchy of Developments) (Scotland) Regulations 2009.

11 November 2025

Question: S6W-41363

Ariane Burgess (Highlands and Islands) (Scottish Green Party): To ask the Scottish Government what assessment it has made of the carbon footprint of data centres operating in Scotland, how the outcomes of any such assessments align with its net zero targets, and what measures are in place to ensure that new data centres meet environmental sustainability standards, including in relation to energy efficiency and renewable energy use.

Answer

Richard Lochhead: In Scotland, there are a range of data centres serving public and private sector requirements. There has been no overall assessment of the carbon footprint of these facilities in Scotland. 

The European Commission has adopted a new delegated regulation on the first phase for establishing an EU-wide scheme to rate the sustainability of EU data centres which the Scottish Government is monitoring. However significant parts of this directive fall out with the devolved powers of Scottish Parliament. Scottish Government will however consider alignment for parts of the directive that fall within devolved competency. We are in discussion with the UK government around their plans to align UK policy to this directive.

Existing co-location commercial data centre operators have been contacted directly by our economic agencies to explore routes to decarbonise their facilities and operations, with operators being signposted to relevant funding opportunities.

Where proposals for new data centres come forward, our Fourth National Planning Framework (NPF4) ensures their potential impacts are important considerations in planning decision-making. NPF4 needs to be read and applied as a whole, and all applications are subject to site specific assessments.

NPF4 Policy 2 (climate mitigation and adaptation) requires development proposals to be sited and designed to minimise lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions as far as possible. We have published new planning guidance supporting the application of NPF4 policy 2 setting out a proportionate approach to dealing with whole life carbon through the planning process, drawing on recent research and international best practice. 

NPF4 Policy 19 (heating and cooling) sets out that National and Major developments that will generate waste or surplus heat, and which are located in areas of heat demand, should include a Heat and Power Plan to demonstrate how energy recovered from the development will be used to produce electricity and heat.

New data centre buildings must also be designed and constructed in compliance with the relevant building regulations applicable to non-domestic buildings, including standard 6.1 which focuses on the reduction of energy demand arising from the use of heating, hot water, lighting, ventilation and cooling systems in a new building.

Briefing from SPICe (Scottish Parliament Information Centre)

Ariane Burgess’s office also contacted the Scottish Parliament Information Centre (SPICe) to ask them for further informtion about the application fo EIA regulation to Battery Storage and “Green Data Centres”.

This was the reply:

BESS and EIA

With regard BESS, the Scottish Government’s Chief Planner confirms in a letter issued on 27 August 2020 that “The Scottish Government considers that a battery installation generates electricity and is therefore to be treated as a generating station.” This means an EIA would normally be required for any BESS with a development area that exceeds 0.5 hectares which is likely to have significant effects on the environment by virtue of factors such as its nature, size, or location – the “Schedule 2” EIA criteria for an energy related development. Decisions on whether a likely environmental effect is “significant”, and therefore triggers the production of an EIA, rests with the decision-making authority, either the planning authority or Scottish Ministers.

Data Centres and EIA

It is possible that a data centre could fall under the EIA Schedule 2 categories of “Industrial estate projects” or “urban development project”, but this is not clear and would be a matter for policy makers, and ultimately the courts, to decide. Changing the types of development subject to an EIA may be possible through a Scottish Statutory Instrument. However, EIA legislation is a complex mix of EU, UK, and Scottish legislation and you would need to seek expert legal advice on how best to proceed.

Definition of a ‘Green’ Data Centre

It is unclear what qualifies as a “green data centre” in respect of National Planning Framework 4 (NPF4), National Development 12. The Scottish Government has not issued any guidance or advice on what data centres are covered by this policy.

The Scottish Government has issued a longlist (https://digitalconnectivity.campaign.gov.scot/publications/2023/11/long-list-of-datacentre-site-development-report) and shortlist (https://digitalconnectivity.campaign.gov.scot/publications/2023/06/short-list-of-datacentre-site-development-report) of potential green data centre sites. Again, it is unclear whether NPF4 Policy 12 would apply to any of these sites.

Comment From APRS

Dr Kat Jones, Director of APRS said:

“We are very concerned that the Government has no definition or guidance on what constitutes a “Green” data centre. We are seeing applications for huge data centres springing up all over the central belt of Scotland and every one of them is claiming to be “green”. This comes as little surprise when we discover that ‘Green Data Centres’  are being classed by the Government as ‘national developments’, giving them a privileged position in the planning system.

“At present Data centres are saying they are ‘Green’ because they use Scotland’s grid electricity. Under that definition every household and business in Scotland is green.

“The Scottish Government is promoting Scotland as a location for ‘hyperscale’ data centres so they need to have a handle on their environmental impacts. These data centres use mind-bogglingly large amounts of energy with one data centre using the energy equivalent to all the households in a city.

“We need to see leadership from Scottish Government. It is not enough to have warm words about “green” data centres, with no definition of what that is. Data centres will shred our net zero targets to pieces with the energy they are likely to consume unless they are properly regulated.

“We are calling on the Government to require all data centres to be subject to strict environmental and reporting standards. It seems, from the answers to these Parliamentary questions, that those standards do not exist.”

Keep up to date with APRS

Get our new regular bulletin in your inbox.

Name(Required)
Email(Required)
Back
to top