APRS Director Kat Jones and Kim Pratt of Friends of the Earth Scotland gave evidence to the Climate Action Committee’s inquiry into the impact of hyperscale AI data centres in the Scottish Parliament on Thursday 29 October. You can watch some of the key questions answered below:
If you want to watch the whole evidence session you can do so HERE
The evidence session following Friends of the Earth Scotland and APRS, heard from
- Rosi Leonard, Data Centre Campaign Lead & Network Development Coordinator, Friends of the Earth Ireland and
- Professor Hannah Daly, Professor in Sustainable Energy, University College Cork.
Answers from APRS that we think are most useful to listen to
We start with a few key questions that might be of most interest and the other questions are grouped below:
Q1. Do you think we should have data centres, and hyperscale data centres, in Scotland?
In this question Kat explains the difference between data centres and hyperscale AI data centres
Q25. How feasible is it for waste heat from data centres to be captured and used in heat networks?
In this question Kat explains the challenges of using the low grade waste heat produced by data centres, especially in the context of the size of the data centres and amount of heat produced
Ariane Burgess MSP
Q5. What role should communities have in developing the guidance that the government is bringing forward?
Q3. How do you think a green data centre should be defined? What should a green centre have to do or show when making a planning application?
Q8. What impact will hyperscale data centres in Scotland have on emissions?
In this answer Kat talks about the cumulative impacts of 8.9GW in the grid queue and the impacts of the diesel testing regime.
Q11. NESO have suggested that siting data centres in Scotland could reduce [wind curtailment] constraint payments, investment in the transmission grid, and ultimately electricity bills. Do you think that’s accurate?
Kat explains why curtailed wind is not a useful way of justifying the construction of data centres
Q16. The government has previously argued it is for local authorities to make these decisions [on granting planning permission for hyperscale data centres]. How can you deliver a strategic view when it is local authorities who make the decisions?
Kat explain why it is important that planning decisions are taken at local level but that the correct guidance and strategy is provided from Government and reiterates APRS’s calls for the pause to be properly implemented while the work is done.
6. The UK Government recently published The Data Centre Covenant. Do you have any reflections on how we might have a similar agreement in Scotland?
In this answer Kat explains her concerns over the news that the UK Government announcement says that connections for data centres will be prioritised and that, in the meantime, onsite, behind the meter generation will be permitted, and this means gas
Questions on the Irish experience
The second panel was Professor Hannah Daly (University College Cork), Rosi Leonard (Friends of the Earth Ireland) and Ronan Kelly (Digital Infrastructure Ireland, the industry body).
Watch the session (notes of highlights below.)
Data centres’ share of Ireland’s electricity rose from 5% in 2015 to 23% today, the highest per capita rate in the world.
“What Scotland has done now, Ireland should have done in 2015” Rosi Leonard, Friends of the Earth Ireland
Professor Daly explained that Ireland’s connection rules now require on-site generation or storage, and that in practice this has meant gas plants. Seventeen data centres have applied to connect directly to the gas network, which adds up to more than 2GW against a national peak demand of about 6GW. She also warned against treating HVO as a sustainable back-up fuel, because of deforestation risk in its supply chain.
“Renewables bring benefits for the climate and for energy security only if they displace fossil fuels. If they are diverted to meet the needs of a large new energy industry, they bring no climate benefit.” Professor Hannah Daly, University College Cork
Asked by Ariane Burgess what Scotland should do, Professor Daly recommended copying the advice that Ireland’s Climate Change Advisory Council gave and the Irish Government did not adopt. That data centres should run only on additional renewables, matched hour by hour.
“It would make things more challenging, but it would put the onus of environmental responsibility on the data centre developer, rather than on the public.” Professor Hannah Daly, University College Cork
Rosi Leonard referenced research from Friends of the Earth Ireland showing data centres increased the electricity bill for the most disadvantaged households by approximately €209 between 2021 and 2023. She called on Scotland to introduce a national register of energy and water usage and impose sanctions on data centre operators who fail to provide this information. Currently only one in six operators in Ireland have provided this information.
Other Questions
Q2. The Scottish Government has set [a capacity] of 50MW, with anything above that considered hyperscale. Do you think that’s an accurate figure?
In this question
Q4. In your view, what would a responsible hyperscale data centre look like?
In this answer Kat emphasises that the answer to this is not known and call for the pause to be properly implemented while the research is done into the impacts.
Questions from Ariane Burgess MSP
Q7. Do you see a connection between the recent approval of the Jackdaw domestic gas field [and hyperscale data centre developments]?
Questions from Martyn Daye MSP
Q9. Do you think there is any potential for AI to help us reduce emissions?
Q10. How should we be assessing and monitoring the emissions from construction, backup generation and electricity used over the lifetime of data centres?
Question from committee convener
Questions from Claire Baker MSP
Q12. Governments will argue that most of our essential data is not currently held in the UK as we don’t have capacity to store it. There is a potential that we are at the mercy of other countries who will hold our data, [so is there a need for sovereign AI data centres to ensure security of our data]?
Q14. You mentioned earlier about a lack of consultation with communities. Have you had discussions with the government regarding factoring in emissions from data centres into Scotland’s overall figures?
Q15. Would the planning guidance required be unique to AI hyperscale data centres, or are there equivalent planning processes that are as detailed or intricate [for other types of development]?
Q17. Do we have any understanding of the noise impact of hyperscale data centres on local communities? Are there ways that could be mitigated against?
Questions from David Barratt MSP
Q18. Your written submission calls for the government to set out any new planning policy with a statement of need and to tightly define what green data centres are. How do you feel that the statement of need should be framed, and is it about defining our domestic demand or is it seeing an opportunity in international demand?
Q19. We have an existing capacity of 30-40MW in Scotland, and what is proposed is many times that. Do we have an understanding of exactly what the proposed type of hyperscale data centres would be used for, and how easily that can be controlled through regulation and planning?
Q20. These data centres operate in a very globalised market, so does it matter where they’re located?
Q21. Is there a risk that if we don’t get the statement of need that has been called for right, that we offshore our own data centre use making either no impact on climate impacts or making them worse, if we offshore our use to countries that don’t have renewables, for example?
Questions from James Adams MSP
Q22. How do you assess the potential impact of hyperscale data centres on water resources in Scotland, both nationally and at a local catchment level, and how can high levels of water use in data centres be mitigated against?
Q23. What information on water use and environmental performance should these data centre operators be expected to report publicly?
No answer given to water question but comment about circular economy and e-waste arising from data centres.
Questions from Sanne Dijkstra-Downie MSP
Q24. Do you believe [e-waste] is currently receiving enough scrutiny in the planning system?
Q26. [Follow-up question on heat networks] Do you have any reflections on the fact that heat can travel [and therefore you don’t need to build a data centre near to homes to heat them]?
Supplementary questions from Ariane Burgess MSP and Martyn Daye MSP